Egan-Jones Recommends Shareholders Withhold Votes from Jack in the Box Board
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Feb 09 2026
0mins
Should l Buy JACK?
Source: Newsfilter
- Poor Shareholder Returns: Jack in the Box has experienced a 76% total shareholder return decline over the past two years, significantly underperforming its peers and the broader market, indicating severe governance failures and ineffective strategic execution that have led to substantial shareholder value destruction.
- Brand Identity Issues: The company has diluted its unique positioning as a late-night QSR brand over recent years, resulting in a persistent decline in customer traffic, inconsistent messaging, and a broad, unfocused menu strategy that exacerbates operational deterioration.
- Capital Allocation Mistakes: Jack in the Box acquired Del Taco for $585 million in March 2022 but divested it for approximately $115 million in December 2025, reflecting a significant loss of invested capital and highlighting major missteps in management's capital allocation strategy.
- Underwhelming Operational Plan: Despite launching the JACK on Track strategic plan in April 2025 to simplify operations and improve capital allocation, same-store sales fell by 7.4% year-over-year in Q4 FY 2025, and the company only closed 51 locations against a target of 80 to 120, indicating a lack of effective execution.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy JACK?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on JACK
Wall Street analysts forecast JACK stock price to fall
15 Analyst Rating
3 Buy
11 Hold
1 Sell
Hold
Current: 20.500
Low
15.00
Averages
19.35
High
25.00
Current: 20.500
Low
15.00
Averages
19.35
High
25.00
About JACK
Jack in the Box Inc. is a restaurant company. The Company operates and franchises Jack in the Box, a hamburger chain with approximately 2,135 restaurants across 21 states. Jack in the Box restaurants offer products, including classic burgers like its Jumbo Jack and product lines, such as the Buttery Jack and Smash Jack burgers. Jack offers products, such as breakfast sandwiches with cracked eggs, as well as tacos, curly fries, egg rolls, specialty sandwiches and real ice cream shakes, among many other items. Its menu offers breakfast, lunch, dinner, snacks, and late-night. Jack in the Box allows its guests to customize meals to their tastes and order any product on the menu when they want it, including breakfast at night, or burgers and chicken in the morning.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Biglari Capital Issues Strong Criticism of JACK's Board Leadership
- Significant Shareholder Losses: Over the past five years, shareholders of Jack in the Box Inc. have lost approximately $1.8 billion, equating to 80% of the company's value, indicating severe failures in leadership and strategic decision-making that directly impact the company's financial health and market confidence.
- Governance Structure Issues: The board is composed of long-tenured directors lacking restaurant industry expertise, overly reliant on Chairman David Goebel's advice, leading to a series of problems including the failed Del Taco acquisition and the lowest same-store sales since the pandemic, reflecting the board's structural weaknesses.
- Escalating Financial Crisis: Due to Goebel's outdated experience, JACK has been forced to suspend dividends, close 150 to 200 stores, and restructure its business, highlighting the increasingly severe financial predicament the company faces, which could lead to deeper financial distress if the status quo continues.
- Shareholder Voting Appeal: Biglari Capital strongly urges shareholders to vote against Goebel's re-election at the upcoming annual meeting, aiming to reverse the company's current predicament by changing leadership and ensuring constructive dialogue between the board and management.
See More
Biglari Capital Strongly Opposes JACK Board Leadership
- Significant Shareholder Losses: Jack in the Box Inc. shareholders have lost approximately $1.8 billion, equating to an 80% decline in company value over the past five years, indicating severe mismanagement that necessitates urgent reform to restore investor confidence.
- Leadership Instability: The company has seen three CEOs and eight CFOs in the last five years, reflecting a fragile governance structure that has led to ongoing strategic uncertainty and diminished market trust.
- Board's Reliance on Outdated Experience: David Goebel's nearly three-decade-old restaurant experience has resulted in the board lacking fresh perspectives in critical decisions, forcing the company to close 150-200 stores and suspend dividends, putting its financial health at serious risk.
- Shareholder Voting Appeal: Biglari Capital urges all shareholders to vote against David Goebel's re-election at the upcoming annual meeting to break his control over the board, drive necessary governance reforms, and ensure sustainable future growth.
See More
Jack in the Box Revives Classic Hot Mess Burger Amid Turnaround Efforts
- Classic Burger Revival: Jack in the Box announced the return of its classic Hot Mess Burger in celebration of its 75th anniversary, although it will only be available at select locations in the U.S., aiming to attract customers and boost sales.
- Store Closure Strategy: The company is executing its 'Jack on Track' plan, projected to close 150-200 underperforming restaurants, having already closed 86 in fiscal year 2025, demonstrating its commitment to optimizing its business model.
- Earnings Forecast: Wall Street analysts expect Jack in the Box to report first-quarter revenue of $354.44 million, a 1.4% increase year-over-year, with earnings per share projected at $1.11, down from $1.16 last year, reflecting cautious market sentiment regarding growth.
- Market Sentiment Shift: According to Stocktwits data, retail sentiment on Jack in the Box shifted from 'bearish' to 'extremely bearish', with message volumes surging 29% in the last 24 hours, indicating investor pessimism ahead of the upcoming earnings report.
See More
Jack in the Box Revives Nostalgic Hot Mess Burger for 75th Anniversary
- Burger Comeback: Jack in the Box announces the return of the fan-favorite Hot Mess Burger on February 16 at participating locations and in the Jack app, fulfilling years of customer demand and expected to drive sales growth and attract new customers.
- Ad Remake and Commemorative Events: To celebrate its 75th anniversary, Jack in the Box will remake the original ad and launch limited-edition collectibles, aiming to enhance customer loyalty and brand recognition through a deeper emotional connection with its story.
- Anniversary Tour Launch: The Hot Mess Burger Anniversary Tour kicks off in San Diego on February 13 and runs through February 21, featuring unique events in cities like Los Angeles and Austin, designed to engage consumers and showcase the burger's appeal.
- Classic Merchandise Return: Jack's iconic antenna balls will also make a comeback as nostalgic merchandise, aiming to strengthen the brand's cultural impact while attracting both loyal fans and a new generation of consumers.
See More
Biglari Capital Sends Letter to Jack in the Box Shareholders
- Shareholder Voting Importance: On February 9, 2026, Biglari Capital Corp. sent a letter to shareholders of Jack in the Box Inc., emphasizing that every vote matters regardless of the number of shares owned, aiming to enhance shareholder engagement and influence corporate decisions.
- Proxy Card Voting Appeal: Biglari Capital urges shareholders to sign, date, and promptly return the GOLD proxy card to ensure their voices are effectively heard in the upcoming vote, thereby increasing their influence in corporate governance.
- Voting Support Channels: Shareholders needing assistance with voting or copies of Biglari Capital's proxy materials can contact Saratoga Proxy Consulting LLC, which provided a phone number and email address to facilitate smooth participation in the voting process.
- Company Background: Biglari Capital Corp. is an investment firm headquartered in San Antonio, Texas, focused on driving value in its portfolio companies through active shareholder engagement, showcasing its dynamic role in the capital markets.
See More
Biglari Capital Sends Letter to Jack in the Box Shareholders
- Shareholder Voting Importance: On February 9, 2026, Biglari Capital Corp. sent a letter to shareholders of Jack in the Box Inc., emphasizing the critical nature of shareholder voting regardless of the number of shares owned, aiming to enhance shareholder engagement and influence corporate governance.
- Proxy Card Return Appeal: The firm urges shareholders to sign, date, and promptly return the GOLD proxy card to ensure their voting rights are exercised, which could potentially impact future company decisions.
- Voting Support Channels: Biglari Capital provides contact information for Saratoga Proxy Consulting LLC, facilitating shareholders in obtaining assistance or proxy materials during the voting process, demonstrating the company's commitment to shareholder service.
- Company Background: Biglari Capital Corp. is an investment firm headquartered in San Antonio, Texas, focused on driving value enhancement in its portfolio companies through active shareholder participation.
See More
Biglari Capital Issues Strong Criticism of JACK's Board Leadership
- Significant Shareholder Losses: Over the past five years, shareholders of Jack in the Box Inc. have lost approximately $1.8 billion, equating to 80% of the company's value, indicating severe failures in leadership and strategic decision-making that directly impact the company's financial health and market confidence.
- Governance Structure Issues: The board is composed of long-tenured directors lacking restaurant industry expertise, overly reliant on Chairman David Goebel's advice, leading to a series of problems including the failed Del Taco acquisition and the lowest same-store sales since the pandemic, reflecting the board's structural weaknesses.
- Escalating Financial Crisis: Due to Goebel's outdated experience, JACK has been forced to suspend dividends, close 150 to 200 stores, and restructure its business, highlighting the increasingly severe financial predicament the company faces, which could lead to deeper financial distress if the status quo continues.
- Shareholder Voting Appeal: Biglari Capital strongly urges shareholders to vote against Goebel's re-election at the upcoming annual meeting, aiming to reverse the company's current predicament by changing leadership and ensuring constructive dialogue between the board and management.
See More
Biglari Capital Strongly Opposes JACK Board Leadership
- Significant Shareholder Losses: Jack in the Box Inc. shareholders have lost approximately $1.8 billion, equating to an 80% decline in company value over the past five years, indicating severe mismanagement that necessitates urgent reform to restore investor confidence.
- Leadership Instability: The company has seen three CEOs and eight CFOs in the last five years, reflecting a fragile governance structure that has led to ongoing strategic uncertainty and diminished market trust.
- Board's Reliance on Outdated Experience: David Goebel's nearly three-decade-old restaurant experience has resulted in the board lacking fresh perspectives in critical decisions, forcing the company to close 150-200 stores and suspend dividends, putting its financial health at serious risk.
- Shareholder Voting Appeal: Biglari Capital urges all shareholders to vote against David Goebel's re-election at the upcoming annual meeting to break his control over the board, drive necessary governance reforms, and ensure sustainable future growth.
See More
Jack in the Box Revives Classic Hot Mess Burger Amid Turnaround Efforts
- Classic Burger Revival: Jack in the Box announced the return of its classic Hot Mess Burger in celebration of its 75th anniversary, although it will only be available at select locations in the U.S., aiming to attract customers and boost sales.
- Store Closure Strategy: The company is executing its 'Jack on Track' plan, projected to close 150-200 underperforming restaurants, having already closed 86 in fiscal year 2025, demonstrating its commitment to optimizing its business model.
- Earnings Forecast: Wall Street analysts expect Jack in the Box to report first-quarter revenue of $354.44 million, a 1.4% increase year-over-year, with earnings per share projected at $1.11, down from $1.16 last year, reflecting cautious market sentiment regarding growth.
- Market Sentiment Shift: According to Stocktwits data, retail sentiment on Jack in the Box shifted from 'bearish' to 'extremely bearish', with message volumes surging 29% in the last 24 hours, indicating investor pessimism ahead of the upcoming earnings report.
See More
Jack in the Box Revives Nostalgic Hot Mess Burger for 75th Anniversary
- Burger Comeback: Jack in the Box announces the return of the fan-favorite Hot Mess Burger on February 16 at participating locations and in the Jack app, fulfilling years of customer demand and expected to drive sales growth and attract new customers.
- Ad Remake and Commemorative Events: To celebrate its 75th anniversary, Jack in the Box will remake the original ad and launch limited-edition collectibles, aiming to enhance customer loyalty and brand recognition through a deeper emotional connection with its story.
- Anniversary Tour Launch: The Hot Mess Burger Anniversary Tour kicks off in San Diego on February 13 and runs through February 21, featuring unique events in cities like Los Angeles and Austin, designed to engage consumers and showcase the burger's appeal.
- Classic Merchandise Return: Jack's iconic antenna balls will also make a comeback as nostalgic merchandise, aiming to strengthen the brand's cultural impact while attracting both loyal fans and a new generation of consumers.
See More
Biglari Capital Sends Letter to Jack in the Box Shareholders
- Shareholder Voting Importance: On February 9, 2026, Biglari Capital Corp. sent a letter to shareholders of Jack in the Box Inc., emphasizing that every vote matters regardless of the number of shares owned, aiming to enhance shareholder engagement and influence corporate decisions.
- Proxy Card Voting Appeal: Biglari Capital urges shareholders to sign, date, and promptly return the GOLD proxy card to ensure their voices are effectively heard in the upcoming vote, thereby increasing their influence in corporate governance.
- Voting Support Channels: Shareholders needing assistance with voting or copies of Biglari Capital's proxy materials can contact Saratoga Proxy Consulting LLC, which provided a phone number and email address to facilitate smooth participation in the voting process.
- Company Background: Biglari Capital Corp. is an investment firm headquartered in San Antonio, Texas, focused on driving value in its portfolio companies through active shareholder engagement, showcasing its dynamic role in the capital markets.
See More
Biglari Capital Sends Letter to Jack in the Box Shareholders
- Shareholder Voting Importance: On February 9, 2026, Biglari Capital Corp. sent a letter to shareholders of Jack in the Box Inc., emphasizing the critical nature of shareholder voting regardless of the number of shares owned, aiming to enhance shareholder engagement and influence corporate governance.
- Proxy Card Return Appeal: The firm urges shareholders to sign, date, and promptly return the GOLD proxy card to ensure their voting rights are exercised, which could potentially impact future company decisions.
- Voting Support Channels: Biglari Capital provides contact information for Saratoga Proxy Consulting LLC, facilitating shareholders in obtaining assistance or proxy materials during the voting process, demonstrating the company's commitment to shareholder service.
- Company Background: Biglari Capital Corp. is an investment firm headquartered in San Antonio, Texas, focused on driving value enhancement in its portfolio companies through active shareholder participation.
See More
