Should I Buy TOL? TOL 2026 Analysis

Should You Buy Toll Brothers Inc (TOL) Today? Analysis, Price Targets, and 2026 Outlook.

Conclusion

Hold

Latest Price

153.280

1 Day change

1.78%

52 Week Range

155.520

Analysis Updated At

2026/01/30

Should I buy Analysis is updated weekly. For real time "Should I Buy" analysis, please sign up to get free answers.

TOL is not a good buy right now for an impatient buyer. Price is below the key pivot (146.11) with a weakening momentum setup (MACD histogram negative and expanding) ahead of the Feb 18 earnings catalyst, while fundamentals show margin/income pressure. If you must act immediately, the risk/reward is not favorable versus waiting for either a cleaner bounce off ~142.5 support or a reclaim of 146–150 resistance. Net: hold off on buying at current levels.

Technical Analysis

Trend/structure is mixed-to-cautious near term. The moving average stack is still bullish (SMA_5 > SMA_20 > SMA_200), which supports the bigger-picture uptrend, but momentum is deteriorating: MACD histogram is -0.216 and negatively expanding, signaling increasing downside momentum. RSI(6) ~48 is neutral, implying no oversold edge to buy immediately. Key levels: pivot 146.11 (current price ~144.7 is below it), support S1 142.53 then S2 140.31; resistance R1 149.69 then R2 151.91. With price under the pivot and MACD worsening, the path of least resistance is a test of 142.5 before a durable rebound.

Intellectia Proprietary Trading Signals

AI Stock Picker: No signal on given stock today.
SwingMax: No signal on given stock recently.

Pattern-based forward view provided: ~40% chance of -0.24% next day, +3.8% next week, -5.1% next month (tilts choppy/soft over a month).

Options Data

Neutral

Open Interest Put-Call Ratio

Bullish

Option Volume Put-Call Ratio

Options sentiment is mixed. Open interest put/call ~1.01 is essentially neutral (slightly defensive positioning), while the put/call by volume at 0.31 is bullish (calls dominating today’s flow). However, implied volatility is elevated (30D IV ~42.37; IV percentile ~83.6), suggesting the market is pricing notable event risk/uncertainty (consistent with the upcoming earnings). Elevated IV also implies options are expensive, which often coincides with greater short-term price swings rather than a clean trend.

Technical Summary

Sell

Buy

Positive Catalysts

- Hedge fund flow: “Hedge Funds are Buying,” with buying amount up ~289.76% QoQ (institutional accumulation signal).
- Product/news flow: multiple new luxury community/model launches (AZ, GA, TX, CA) support backlog replenishment narrative, even if not a major near-term earnings driver.
- Earnings event catalyst: Q1 earnings call on Feb 18, 2026 could re-rate shares if orders/margins surprise positively.
- Wall Street bull case: several Buy/Outperform ratings highlight less rate-sensitive buyer mix (move-up/active adult) and shareholder returns (buybacks/dividends).

Neutral/Negative Catalysts

- Near-term momentum deterioration: MACD is negative and worsening, and price is below the 146.11 pivot—setup favors a support test rather than immediate upside.
- Macro/industry headwinds cited by analysts: more competitive selling environment, elevated inventory, weaker migration/employment trends; some call 2026 a “reset year” for homebuilders.
- Fundamental pressure: latest reported quarter shows margin and profit compression (gross margin down YoY; net income down YoY).
- Event risk into earnings with high IV: elevated implied volatility indicates the market expects a meaningful move, increasing downside risk if guidance/order trends disappoint.
- No supportive insider trend: insiders are neutral (no notable recent bullish insider buying signal).

Financial Performance

Latest quarter: 2025/Q4. Revenue grew to $3.423B (+2.70% YoY), but profitability weakened: net income $446.7M (-6.04% YoY), EPS 4.58 (-1.08% YoY), and gross margin 25.48% (-3.56% YoY). The key takeaway is modest top-line growth but deteriorating margins/earnings—consistent with a more promotional/competitive environment and aligns with several analysts cutting FY26 expectations.

Growth

Profitability

Efficiency

Analyst Ratings and Price Target Trends

Recent Street trend: December 2025 featured multiple price target cuts after earnings/guidance (JPM to $141, Citi to $141, RBC to $144, GS to $140, KBW to $143), reflecting softer margin/outlook concerns. Since then, tone improved at the start of January: Citizens initiated Outperform with a $175 target (Jan 7) and BofA raised its target to $160 and reiterated Buy (Jan 16). Overall, ratings skew constructive (several Buys/Outperforms remain), but the dominant near-term message is “fundamentals may be pressured through 2026,” with valuation/supportive positioning as the main pro.

Wall Street pros: higher-end demand base perceived as less rate sensitive; history of execution (deliveries often above midpoint); shareholder returns; some see 2026 improving. Wall Street cons: margin compression/incentives; softer housing market; higher inventory/competition; 2026 seen as a reset year; multiple PT cuts signal tempered expectations.

Politician/congress trades: No recent congress trading data available in the last 90 days.

TOL Should I Buy