Should I Buy AFG? AFG 2026 Analysis

Should You Buy American Financial Group Inc (AFG) Today? Analysis, Price Targets, and 2026 Outlook.

Conclusion

Hold

Latest Price

131.040

1 Day change

1.05%

52 Week Range

150.020

Analysis Updated At

2026/02/04

Should I buy Analysis is updated weekly. For real time "Should I Buy" analysis, please sign up to get free answers.

Not a good buy right now for an impatient entry: trend structure is still bearish (SMA_200 > SMA_20 > SMA_5) and the stock is sitting just below the pivot (~129.35) after a weak post-market move (-2.5%).
Options positioning is very call-heavy (bullish sentiment), but that alone doesn’t offset the weaker technical setup and the notable increase in insider selling.
Earnings/news are fundamentally supportive (EPS beat, special dividend), yet price action suggests the market already priced in a lot and/or is “selling the news.”
Intellectia Proprietary Trading Signals
- AI Stock Picker: No signal on given stock today.
- SwingMax: No signal on given stock today.

Technical Analysis

Primary trend: bearish/late-downtrend structure with moving averages stacked bearishly (SMA_200 > SMA_20 > SMA_5), implying rallies can face overhead supply.
Momentum: improving short-term (MACD histogram +0.184 and expanding), suggesting a bounce attempt is possible, but not yet a confirmed trend reversal.
RSI(6) ~55.5: neutral—no clear overbought/oversold edge.
Key levels:
- Support: S1 ~126.78 (current price ~127 is very close—if it breaks, next is S2 ~125.19).
- Resistance: Pivot ~129.35 then R1 ~131.93 (needs reclaim to look like a cleaner long).
Near-term path: technicals favor “range-to-down” until price reclaims ~129–132 with follow-through.

Options Data

Bullish

Open Interest Put-Call Ratio

Bullish

Option Volume Put-Call Ratio

Sentiment: strongly bullish/call-skewed (OI put/call 0.26; volume put/call 0.01).
Activity: today’s options volume 533 vs 30D average is elevated (today vs avg ~1366%), showing heightened attention.
Volatility: IV30 ~29.32 with IV percentile ~84.4 (options relatively expensive vs its own history), which often happens around/after event catalysts; it can also imply the “easy” post-event move may already be partly priced.

Technical Summary

Sell

Buy

Positive Catalysts

- Q4 2025 results beat expectations: non-GAAP EPS 3.65 reported as above expectations; core net operating earnings rose to $305M.
- Reported net earnings of $299M (+17.3% YoY per news summary).
- Shareholder returns/catalyst: special cash dividend of $1.50/share and $707M returned to shareholders (supports valuation floor and sentiment).
- Options market is positioned bullishly (call-heavy), which can support near-term dip-buying.

Neutral/Negative Catalysts

- Post-market drop (-2.50%) signals immediate selling pressure after the latest updates; for an impatient buyer, that’s poor timing/confirmation.
- Insider activity: insiders are selling, with selling amount up ~101.46% over the last month (a meaningful negative sentiment datapoint).
- Longer-term technical trend still bearish via moving averages; MACD improvement hasn’t flipped the broader trend.
- Revenue pressure: revenue declined (news cites -4.2% to $2.06B; financial snapshot shows -2.96% YoY), suggesting top-line growth is not the driver.
- Congress/politician trading: no recent data available (no supportive “influential buyer” signal).

Financial Performance

Latest quarter: 2025/Q4.
Mixed snapshot vs news flow:
- Revenue: down YoY (financial snapshot: $2.063B, -2.96% YoY; news also notes revenue decline).
- Earnings: news reports strong profitability (net earnings $299M; core operating earnings $305M; non-GAAP EPS 3.65), indicating operational performance held up despite lower revenue.
- The provided financial snapshot lists Net Income/EPS as 0 (-100% YoY), which conflicts with the earnings news; directionally, the quarter appears earnings-positive but with soft revenue.
Capital return focus is a positive quality signal (special dividend + large shareholder returns).

Growth

Profitability

Efficiency

Analyst Ratings and Price Target Trends

Recent analyst action (latest provided): Piper Sandler (2025-11-06) maintained Neutral and raised price target to $139 from $130.
Wall Street pro view (pros): acknowledges steadier underlying premium trends excluding crop timing; higher PT suggests limited downside from prior levels.
Wall Street con view (cons): keeping Neutral implies limited conviction for strong upside; also highlights business mix/timing impacts (crop premiums) that can muddy growth visibility.
Net takeaway: analysts are not broadly pounding the table to buy; stance is more “quality/steady, but not a must-own at this price without a cleaner technical reset.”

2 Analyst Rating

Wall Street analysts forecast AFG stock price to rise over the next 12 months. According to Wall Street analysts, the average 1-year price target for AFG is 137.5 USD with a low forecast of 136 USD and a high forecast of 139 USD. However, analyst price targets are subjective and often lag stock prices, so investors should focus on the objective reasons behind analyst rating changes, which better reflect the company's fundamentals.

0 Buy

2 Hold

0 Sell

Hold

Current: 129.680

Low

136

Averages

137.5

High

139

Current: 129.680

Low

136

Averages

137.5

High

139

Piper Sandler

Neutral

maintain

$130 -> $139

AI Analysis

2025-11-06

Reason

Piper Sandler

Price Target

$130 -> $139

AI Analysis

2025-11-06

maintain

Neutral

Reason

Piper Sandler raised the firm's price target on American Financial Group to $139 from $130 and keeps a Neutral rating on the shares following quarterly results. Net written premiums were impacted by the timing of crop premiums but excluding the crop impact, they were flat year-over-year, the firm notes.

Keefe Bruyette

Meyer Shields

Market Perform

downgrade

$127 -> $124

2025-08-12

Reason

Keefe Bruyette

Meyer Shields

Price Target

$127 -> $124

2025-08-12

downgrade

Market Perform

Reason

Keefe Bruyette analyst Meyer Shields lowered the firm's price target on American Financial Group to $124 from $127 and keeps a Market Perform rating on the shares. In the near-term, limited reserve releases and high casualty loss picks will likely limit upside, the analyst tells investors in a research note.

Unlock Full Analyst Thesis， Get the complete breakdown of rating reason for AFG

Unlock Now

AFG Should I Buy

AFG Should I Buy

Should You Buy American Financial Group Inc (AFG) Today? Analysis, Price Targets, and 2026 Outlook.

Technical Analysis

Options Data

Technical Summary

Positive Catalysts

Neutral/Negative Catalysts

Financial Performance

Growth

Profitability

Efficiency

Analyst Ratings and Price Target Trends

People Also Watch