Supreme Court Delays Ruling on Trump's Tariffs, $150B Refunds at Stake
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Jan 09 2026
0mins
Source: Benzinga
- Tariff Case Pending: The U.S. Supreme Court did not issue a ruling on Trump's global tariffs, with traders pricing in a 75% chance of a favorable outcome for Trump, leaving $150 billion in refunds at stake, which could significantly impact major companies' financials.
- Escalating Legal Challenges: Major firms, including Costco and Alcoa, have filed lawsuits against the tariffs seeking refunds and injunctions against future tariffs, reflecting corporate dissatisfaction and concerns over financial implications.
- Market Reaction Expectations: Crypto traders argue that striking down Trump's tariffs would provide multiple catalysts for Bitcoin and other risk assets, as market clarity improves and corporate cost pressures ease, potentially enhancing earnings outlooks.
- Power Test: This case represents a significant test of presidential powers and will impact the global economy, with any rollback of tariffs likely to be slow and complex rather than an immediate removal of all trade barriers.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy AA?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on AA
Wall Street analysts forecast AA stock price to fall over the next 12 months. According to Wall Street analysts, the average 1-year price target for AA is 46.00 USD with a low forecast of 33.00 USD and a high forecast of 58.00 USD. However, analyst price targets are subjective and often lag stock prices, so investors should focus on the objective reasons behind analyst rating changes, which better reflect the company's fundamentals.
10 Analyst Rating
6 Buy
2 Hold
2 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 56.380
Low
33.00
Averages
46.00
High
58.00
Current: 56.380
Low
33.00
Averages
46.00
High
58.00
About AA
Alcoa Corporation is a vertically integrated aluminum company comprised of bauxite mining, alumina refining, aluminum production (smelting and casting), and energy generation. The Company’s operations are comprised of two business segments: Alumina and Aluminum. The Alumina segment primarily consists of its bauxite mines and alumina refineries, which generally include the mining of bauxite and other aluminous ores, as well as the refining, production, and sale of smelter grade and non-metallurgical alumina. The alumina produced by this segment is sold to internal and external aluminum smelter customers; a portion of the alumina is sold to external customers who process it into industrial chemical products. The Aluminum segment consists of the Company’s aluminum smelting and casting operations along with the Company’s energy production assets in Brazil, Canada, and the United States. It has direct and indirect ownership of 26 operating locations across nine countries on six continents.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Dow Jones Index Surpasses 50,000 for the First Time
- Historic Milestone: The Dow Jones Industrial Average surpassed 50,000 for the first time in 2026, marking a significant achievement since its inception in 1896, reflecting sustained investor confidence amid economic fluctuations.
- Tech Stock Influence: This milestone was largely driven by strong performances from technology stocks, particularly Nvidia's replacement of Intel, highlighting the market's heightened focus and investment enthusiasm in the artificial intelligence sector.
- Market Rebound: Following a downturn in 2022, the Dow rebounded nearly 13% in 2023, with this breakthrough occurring against the backdrop of the index climbing over 1,100 points, demonstrating a robust market recovery.
- Changing Economic Landscape: Despite concerns over Trump's tariff policies and the impact of AI spending, the market has shown resilience, indicating investor optimism regarding future economic growth.
See More
Aluminum Prices Surge to Four-Year High as Dollar Weakens
- Aluminum Price Surge: Aluminum futures on the London Metal Exchange rose 2.3% to $3,387 per metric ton, marking a nearly four-year high, reflecting strong demand for base metals and bullish investor sentiment.
- Dollar Weakness Impact: Trump's comments expressing indifference towards the dollar's decline intensified bearish sentiment in the market, leading to price increases in aluminum and other base metals, with copper up 1.5% and zinc up 1.9%.
- Goldman Sachs Upgrades Outlook: Goldman Sachs raised its aluminum price forecast for H1 2023 from $2,575 to $3,150 per ton, although still below current prices, indicating strong confidence in the aluminum market and sustained investor optimism.
- Supply and Demand Dynamics: Low global aluminum inventories and concerns over power availability for new Indonesian smelters, coupled with rising demand from electric vehicles and grid requirements, have supported the price rally, despite Goldman forecasting a drop to $2,400 per ton in the future.
See More
Alcoa Stock Rises Despite Downgrade by Morgan Stanley
- Rating Downgrade: Morgan Stanley downgraded Alcoa (AA) from Overweight to Equal Weight with a $64 price target, citing a more balanced risk-reward after the stock's nearly 50% rise since December 1.
- Productivity Initiatives: Alcoa is implementing several measures to enhance productivity, reduce costs, and optimize its asset portfolio, while also expecting $50M-$60M annually in IRA production tax credits for U.S. aluminum, bolstering profitability.
- Market Conditions: A tighter aluminum market is expected to sustain profitability, with U.S. regional premiums reflecting a 50% tariff; Alcoa has identified 10 high-priority curtailed sites for potential conversion to hyperscale data centers.
- Transaction Delays: The timeline for transforming curtailed sites into data centers continues to be pushed back, and escalating trade tensions between the U.S. and Canada suggest that obtaining a Section 232 exemption for Canadian aluminum may become more challenging.
See More
Latest Ratings and Outlook from Wall Street
- Cantor's Positive Outlook on Strategy: Cantor Fitzgerald initiates Strategy with an overweight rating, suggesting that the crypto company is well-positioned for the bitcoin cycle, indicating now is a compelling time to invest in this financial engineering innovator.
- Citi's Bullish Stance on Novartis: Citi initiates Novartis as a buy, forecasting 4-5% sales growth for 2025-2030, which exceeds the consensus estimate of 3.5-4.0%, highlighting the company's consistent earnings performance.
- TD Cowen Upgrades Zimmer Biomet: TD Cowen upgrades Zimmer Biomet from hold to buy, citing the company's commitment to innovation and management strategies that are expected to drive stock price appreciation.
- Morgan Stanley Downgrades Alcoa: Morgan Stanley downgrades Alcoa from overweight to equal weight, noting that the stock has significantly outperformed peers recently, leading to a more balanced risk-reward scenario.
See More
Alcoa (AA) Reports Q4 Earnings Beat with $226M Net Income Amid Rising Aluminum Prices
- Earnings Beat: Alcoa's Q4 adjusted earnings per share of $1.26 exceeded Wall Street expectations, with net income rising to $226 million from $202 million year-over-year, demonstrating enhanced profitability amid rising aluminum prices.
- Slight Revenue Decline: Q4 revenues slipped 1% year-over-year to $3.45 billion, yet remained slightly above analyst consensus, driven by a 3% increase in alumina segment revenues and a 21% rise in aluminum business, reflecting resilient market demand.
- Future Production Outlook: Alcoa anticipates total alumina production of 9.7 to 9.9 million metric tons in FY 2026, an increase from 2025, indicating positive progress in productivity improvements that may further strengthen market competitiveness.
- Complex Analyst Views: While Q4 adjusted EBITDA of $546 million topped expectations, UBS noted that this included $57 million in one-off CO2 credits, and stripping these away revealed that actual performance missed the mark, suggesting potential challenges ahead.
See More
Alcoa Corporation (AA) Options Trading Volume Hits 32,799 Contracts, 42% of Daily Average
- Active Options Trading: Alcoa Corporation (AA) recorded an options trading volume of 32,799 contracts today, representing approximately 3.3 million shares, which is about 42% of its average daily trading volume of 7.8 million shares over the past month, indicating heightened market interest in its performance.
- High Strike Call Options: Notably, the $65 strike call option expiring on February 20, 2026, has seen significant activity with 3,671 contracts traded today, representing around 367,100 underlying shares of AA, suggesting bullish sentiment among investors regarding its stock price.
- Marvell Technology Options Activity: Marvell Technology Inc (MRVL) experienced an options trading volume of 54,723 contracts today, equating to approximately 5.5 million shares, or about 41.1% of its average daily trading volume of 13.3 million shares over the past month, reflecting strong market engagement.
- Focus on Call Options: The $80 strike call option for MRVL, expiring on January 30, 2026, has also attracted attention with 2,067 contracts traded today, representing approximately 206,700 underlying shares, indicating investor confidence in its future growth prospects.
See More
Dow Jones Index Surpasses 50,000 for the First Time
- Historic Milestone: The Dow Jones Industrial Average surpassed 50,000 for the first time in 2026, marking a significant achievement since its inception in 1896, reflecting sustained investor confidence amid economic fluctuations.
- Tech Stock Influence: This milestone was largely driven by strong performances from technology stocks, particularly Nvidia's replacement of Intel, highlighting the market's heightened focus and investment enthusiasm in the artificial intelligence sector.
- Market Rebound: Following a downturn in 2022, the Dow rebounded nearly 13% in 2023, with this breakthrough occurring against the backdrop of the index climbing over 1,100 points, demonstrating a robust market recovery.
- Changing Economic Landscape: Despite concerns over Trump's tariff policies and the impact of AI spending, the market has shown resilience, indicating investor optimism regarding future economic growth.
See More
Aluminum Prices Surge to Four-Year High as Dollar Weakens
- Aluminum Price Surge: Aluminum futures on the London Metal Exchange rose 2.3% to $3,387 per metric ton, marking a nearly four-year high, reflecting strong demand for base metals and bullish investor sentiment.
- Dollar Weakness Impact: Trump's comments expressing indifference towards the dollar's decline intensified bearish sentiment in the market, leading to price increases in aluminum and other base metals, with copper up 1.5% and zinc up 1.9%.
- Goldman Sachs Upgrades Outlook: Goldman Sachs raised its aluminum price forecast for H1 2023 from $2,575 to $3,150 per ton, although still below current prices, indicating strong confidence in the aluminum market and sustained investor optimism.
- Supply and Demand Dynamics: Low global aluminum inventories and concerns over power availability for new Indonesian smelters, coupled with rising demand from electric vehicles and grid requirements, have supported the price rally, despite Goldman forecasting a drop to $2,400 per ton in the future.
See More
Alcoa Stock Rises Despite Downgrade by Morgan Stanley
- Rating Downgrade: Morgan Stanley downgraded Alcoa (AA) from Overweight to Equal Weight with a $64 price target, citing a more balanced risk-reward after the stock's nearly 50% rise since December 1.
- Productivity Initiatives: Alcoa is implementing several measures to enhance productivity, reduce costs, and optimize its asset portfolio, while also expecting $50M-$60M annually in IRA production tax credits for U.S. aluminum, bolstering profitability.
- Market Conditions: A tighter aluminum market is expected to sustain profitability, with U.S. regional premiums reflecting a 50% tariff; Alcoa has identified 10 high-priority curtailed sites for potential conversion to hyperscale data centers.
- Transaction Delays: The timeline for transforming curtailed sites into data centers continues to be pushed back, and escalating trade tensions between the U.S. and Canada suggest that obtaining a Section 232 exemption for Canadian aluminum may become more challenging.
See More
Latest Ratings and Outlook from Wall Street
- Cantor's Positive Outlook on Strategy: Cantor Fitzgerald initiates Strategy with an overweight rating, suggesting that the crypto company is well-positioned for the bitcoin cycle, indicating now is a compelling time to invest in this financial engineering innovator.
- Citi's Bullish Stance on Novartis: Citi initiates Novartis as a buy, forecasting 4-5% sales growth for 2025-2030, which exceeds the consensus estimate of 3.5-4.0%, highlighting the company's consistent earnings performance.
- TD Cowen Upgrades Zimmer Biomet: TD Cowen upgrades Zimmer Biomet from hold to buy, citing the company's commitment to innovation and management strategies that are expected to drive stock price appreciation.
- Morgan Stanley Downgrades Alcoa: Morgan Stanley downgrades Alcoa from overweight to equal weight, noting that the stock has significantly outperformed peers recently, leading to a more balanced risk-reward scenario.
See More
Alcoa (AA) Reports Q4 Earnings Beat with $226M Net Income Amid Rising Aluminum Prices
- Earnings Beat: Alcoa's Q4 adjusted earnings per share of $1.26 exceeded Wall Street expectations, with net income rising to $226 million from $202 million year-over-year, demonstrating enhanced profitability amid rising aluminum prices.
- Slight Revenue Decline: Q4 revenues slipped 1% year-over-year to $3.45 billion, yet remained slightly above analyst consensus, driven by a 3% increase in alumina segment revenues and a 21% rise in aluminum business, reflecting resilient market demand.
- Future Production Outlook: Alcoa anticipates total alumina production of 9.7 to 9.9 million metric tons in FY 2026, an increase from 2025, indicating positive progress in productivity improvements that may further strengthen market competitiveness.
- Complex Analyst Views: While Q4 adjusted EBITDA of $546 million topped expectations, UBS noted that this included $57 million in one-off CO2 credits, and stripping these away revealed that actual performance missed the mark, suggesting potential challenges ahead.
See More
Alcoa Corporation (AA) Options Trading Volume Hits 32,799 Contracts, 42% of Daily Average
- Active Options Trading: Alcoa Corporation (AA) recorded an options trading volume of 32,799 contracts today, representing approximately 3.3 million shares, which is about 42% of its average daily trading volume of 7.8 million shares over the past month, indicating heightened market interest in its performance.
- High Strike Call Options: Notably, the $65 strike call option expiring on February 20, 2026, has seen significant activity with 3,671 contracts traded today, representing around 367,100 underlying shares of AA, suggesting bullish sentiment among investors regarding its stock price.
- Marvell Technology Options Activity: Marvell Technology Inc (MRVL) experienced an options trading volume of 54,723 contracts today, equating to approximately 5.5 million shares, or about 41.1% of its average daily trading volume of 13.3 million shares over the past month, reflecting strong market engagement.
- Focus on Call Options: The $80 strike call option for MRVL, expiring on January 30, 2026, has also attracted attention with 2,067 contracts traded today, representing approximately 206,700 underlying shares, indicating investor confidence in its future growth prospects.
See More
