Peloton Stock Plummets After Double Earnings Miss and CFO Departure
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: 3d ago
0mins
Should l Buy PTON?
Source: Benzinga
- Double Earnings Miss: Peloton failed to meet analyst expectations for both revenue and profit in the crucial holiday quarter, with CEO Peter Stern attributing the revenue miss to an overestimation of existing members' desire to upgrade their equipment, indicating a significant operational miscalculation.
- Lowered Full-Year Guidance: The company revised its full-year revenue guidance down to between $2.4 billion and $2.44 billion, with Q3 guidance also falling short of analyst estimates, reflecting a concerning trend that could undermine investor confidence moving forward.
- CFO Departure Raises Concerns: CFO Liz Coddington's announcement to step down in March, while stated to be unrelated to financial disagreements, typically raises red flags for investors during challenging turnaround periods, potentially exacerbating market anxiety about Peloton's future.
- Broader Market Sentiment: Despite launching new products and AI features, Peloton's stock is trading near all-time lows, having plummeted over 97% from its 2021 peak, highlighting the company's ongoing struggle to achieve sustainable growth amidst a challenging market environment.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy PTON?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on PTON
Wall Street analysts forecast PTON stock price to rise over the next 12 months. According to Wall Street analysts, the average 1-year price target for PTON is 9.48 USD with a low forecast of 6.50 USD and a high forecast of 14.00 USD. However, analyst price targets are subjective and often lag stock prices, so investors should focus on the objective reasons behind analyst rating changes, which better reflect the company's fundamentals.
12 Analyst Rating
4 Buy
8 Hold
0 Sell
Moderate Buy
Current: 4.390
Low
6.50
Averages
9.48
High
14.00
Current: 4.390
Low
6.50
Averages
9.48
High
14.00
About PTON
Peloton Interactive, Inc. is a global fitness company. The Company is a category innovator at the nexus of fitness, technology, and media, with a subscription platform that combines hardware, distinctive software, and exclusive content. Its segments include Connected Fitness Products and Subscription. The Company’s Connected Fitness Products portfolio includes the Peloton Bike, Bike+, Tread, Tread+, Guide, Row, and various Precor products. Access to the Peloton App is available with an All-Access or Guide Membership for Members who have Connected Fitness Products or through a standalone App Membership with multiple Membership tiers. Access to the Strength+ App is available with an All Access, Guide, or App+ Membership or through a standalone Strength+ subscription. The Company’s subscriptions provide access to Peloton content and its library of live and on-demand fitness classes. The Company’s subscriptions are offered on a month-to-month or prepaid basis.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Peloton Faces Sales Challenges Amid Market Gains
- Sales Decline: Peloton's sales surged to $915 million in fiscal 2020 and exceeded $4 billion by 2022, yet recent reports indicate a 7% year-over-year drop in paid fitness subscriptions, highlighting significant challenges in regaining growth momentum.
- Pricing Strategy Shift: Despite an increase in churn rates, Peloton's management opted to raise prices amid declining sales, reflecting confidence in product enhancements, but this strategy may exacerbate customer attrition risks.
- Narrowing Operating Loss: Peloton's operating loss decreased from $45.9 million to $14.3 million; however, a continued revenue decline of 3% year-over-year indicates that the company has yet to establish a viable path to profitability.
- Valuation Dilemma: With a price-to-sales ratio of 0.7, significantly lower than the S&P 500's 3.4, Peloton's stock may appear undervalued, yet analysts caution that the long-term competitive pressures could render it a value trap, advising investors to tread carefully.
See More
Peloton Stock Faces Long-Term Challenges Amid Market Gains
- Sales Decline: Peloton's sales exceeded $4 billion in fiscal 2022, yet the recently reported second-quarter paid fitness subscriptions fell 7% year-over-year to under 2.7 million, indicating significant post-pandemic customer attrition that pressures revenue growth.
- Pricing Strategy Adjustment: Despite a decrease in subscribers, Peloton's management opted to raise prices, accompanied by some product enhancements; however, this strategy may exacerbate customer churn, leading to a 3% year-over-year revenue decline, reflecting the company's struggles in a competitive market.
- Narrowing Operating Loss: Peloton's operating loss decreased from $45.9 million to $14.3 million, yet ongoing losses and declining revenues raise investor concerns about its future prospects, potentially putting further pressure on the stock price.
- Valuation Trap Risk: With a price-to-sales ratio of 0.7, significantly lower than the S&P 500's 3.4, Peloton may appear undervalued, but due to long-term competitive challenges, investors should exercise caution to avoid falling into a value trap.
See More
Federal Judge Orders Elon Musk to Testify in USAID Case
- Musk Ordered to Testify: A federal judge has ruled that Elon Musk must testify regarding his role in dismantling USAID, rejecting his legal team's attempt to avoid questioning, which could impact Musk's reputation and future business endeavors.
- Alphabet Beats Earnings Estimates: Alphabet reported fourth-quarter revenue of $113.83 billion, surpassing the Street consensus estimate of $111.31 billion, with earnings per share of $2.82 exceeding expectations of $2.63, indicating strong performance in advertising and cloud services that may drive stock price increases.
- Amazon Delivery Milestone: Amazon announced it delivered over 13 billion items globally in 2025, with more than 8 billion items reaching U.S. Prime members the same or next day, a speed enhancement that will further strengthen its competitive position in the e-commerce market.
- Tesla's New Model Launch: Tesla unveiled a new All-Wheel Drive variant of the Model Y in the U.S. and Puerto Rico following Elon Musk's announcement of discontinuing the Model S and X, which could attract more consumers and enhance market share.
See More
Wall Street Analysts Adjust Ratings
- Analyst Rating Changes: Top Wall Street analysts have adjusted their ratings on several companies, reflecting varying market perspectives on their future performance, which could influence investor decisions and market sentiment.
- AMZN Stock Outlook: Analysts' opinions on Amazon (AMZN) stock indicate mixed views on its future growth potential, prompting investors to pay close attention to the latest ratings and recommendations when considering purchases.
- Impact of Rating Changes: Upgrades and downgrades from analysts can lead to stock price volatility, necessitating that investors closely monitor these changes to timely adjust their investment strategies and optimize their portfolios.
- Market Sentiment Reflection: Changes in analyst ratings not only affect individual stock performance but can also impact overall market sentiment, urging investors to consider these factors comprehensively for informed investment decisions.
See More
Stellantis Expects $26 Billion Loss from Overhaul
- Stellantis Stock Plunge: Stellantis anticipates a $26 billion loss due to a business overhaul, causing its U.S.-listed shares to drop over 25% today, reflecting significant investor concerns regarding the company's future outlook.
- Amazon Earnings Miss: Although Amazon exceeded revenue expectations for Q4, its earnings per share fell slightly short of Wall Street forecasts, leading to an 8% decline in its stock today, as investors express caution over its $200 billion capital expenditure plan amid rising AI spending.
- Trump Launches Drug Pricing Platform: Trump officially launched the TrumpRx platform aimed at lowering prescription drug prices in the U.S., though experts are skeptical about its effectiveness in addressing broader affordability issues, as it may not provide lower costs for all patients.
- Bob's Discount Furniture IPO Flat: Bob's Discount Furniture debuted on the NYSE at $17 per share, valuing the company at $2.22 billion, and while its performance was relatively stable, market enthusiasm for upcoming IPOs remains high.
See More
Stellantis Expects $26 Billion Loss from Overhaul
- Stellantis Stock Plunge: Stellantis shares fell over 25% after the automaker announced it expects a $26 billion loss from a business overhaul, marking a tough start to 2026 with shares down more than 12% year-to-date.
- Amazon Earnings Miss: Amazon's stock dropped over 8% despite beating fourth-quarter revenue expectations, as earnings per share fell short, raising investor concerns about its $200 billion capital expenditure plan, which is set to double by the end of 2027.
- Launch of TrumpRx Platform: Former President Trump officially launched the long-anticipated TrumpRx platform aimed at lowering prescription drug prices in the U.S., though experts doubt its effectiveness in addressing broader affordability issues since it does not directly sell drugs.
- Bob's Discount Furniture IPO Performance: Bob's Discount Furniture debuted on the New York Stock Exchange at $17 per share, valuing the company at $2.22 billion, while other retailers like Peloton and Estée Lauder faced significant stock declines, highlighting market volatility.
See More
Peloton Faces Sales Challenges Amid Market Gains
- Sales Decline: Peloton's sales surged to $915 million in fiscal 2020 and exceeded $4 billion by 2022, yet recent reports indicate a 7% year-over-year drop in paid fitness subscriptions, highlighting significant challenges in regaining growth momentum.
- Pricing Strategy Shift: Despite an increase in churn rates, Peloton's management opted to raise prices amid declining sales, reflecting confidence in product enhancements, but this strategy may exacerbate customer attrition risks.
- Narrowing Operating Loss: Peloton's operating loss decreased from $45.9 million to $14.3 million; however, a continued revenue decline of 3% year-over-year indicates that the company has yet to establish a viable path to profitability.
- Valuation Dilemma: With a price-to-sales ratio of 0.7, significantly lower than the S&P 500's 3.4, Peloton's stock may appear undervalued, yet analysts caution that the long-term competitive pressures could render it a value trap, advising investors to tread carefully.
See More
Peloton Stock Faces Long-Term Challenges Amid Market Gains
- Sales Decline: Peloton's sales exceeded $4 billion in fiscal 2022, yet the recently reported second-quarter paid fitness subscriptions fell 7% year-over-year to under 2.7 million, indicating significant post-pandemic customer attrition that pressures revenue growth.
- Pricing Strategy Adjustment: Despite a decrease in subscribers, Peloton's management opted to raise prices, accompanied by some product enhancements; however, this strategy may exacerbate customer churn, leading to a 3% year-over-year revenue decline, reflecting the company's struggles in a competitive market.
- Narrowing Operating Loss: Peloton's operating loss decreased from $45.9 million to $14.3 million, yet ongoing losses and declining revenues raise investor concerns about its future prospects, potentially putting further pressure on the stock price.
- Valuation Trap Risk: With a price-to-sales ratio of 0.7, significantly lower than the S&P 500's 3.4, Peloton may appear undervalued, but due to long-term competitive challenges, investors should exercise caution to avoid falling into a value trap.
See More
Federal Judge Orders Elon Musk to Testify in USAID Case
- Musk Ordered to Testify: A federal judge has ruled that Elon Musk must testify regarding his role in dismantling USAID, rejecting his legal team's attempt to avoid questioning, which could impact Musk's reputation and future business endeavors.
- Alphabet Beats Earnings Estimates: Alphabet reported fourth-quarter revenue of $113.83 billion, surpassing the Street consensus estimate of $111.31 billion, with earnings per share of $2.82 exceeding expectations of $2.63, indicating strong performance in advertising and cloud services that may drive stock price increases.
- Amazon Delivery Milestone: Amazon announced it delivered over 13 billion items globally in 2025, with more than 8 billion items reaching U.S. Prime members the same or next day, a speed enhancement that will further strengthen its competitive position in the e-commerce market.
- Tesla's New Model Launch: Tesla unveiled a new All-Wheel Drive variant of the Model Y in the U.S. and Puerto Rico following Elon Musk's announcement of discontinuing the Model S and X, which could attract more consumers and enhance market share.
See More
Wall Street Analysts Adjust Ratings
- Analyst Rating Changes: Top Wall Street analysts have adjusted their ratings on several companies, reflecting varying market perspectives on their future performance, which could influence investor decisions and market sentiment.
- AMZN Stock Outlook: Analysts' opinions on Amazon (AMZN) stock indicate mixed views on its future growth potential, prompting investors to pay close attention to the latest ratings and recommendations when considering purchases.
- Impact of Rating Changes: Upgrades and downgrades from analysts can lead to stock price volatility, necessitating that investors closely monitor these changes to timely adjust their investment strategies and optimize their portfolios.
- Market Sentiment Reflection: Changes in analyst ratings not only affect individual stock performance but can also impact overall market sentiment, urging investors to consider these factors comprehensively for informed investment decisions.
See More
Stellantis Expects $26 Billion Loss from Overhaul
- Stellantis Stock Plunge: Stellantis anticipates a $26 billion loss due to a business overhaul, causing its U.S.-listed shares to drop over 25% today, reflecting significant investor concerns regarding the company's future outlook.
- Amazon Earnings Miss: Although Amazon exceeded revenue expectations for Q4, its earnings per share fell slightly short of Wall Street forecasts, leading to an 8% decline in its stock today, as investors express caution over its $200 billion capital expenditure plan amid rising AI spending.
- Trump Launches Drug Pricing Platform: Trump officially launched the TrumpRx platform aimed at lowering prescription drug prices in the U.S., though experts are skeptical about its effectiveness in addressing broader affordability issues, as it may not provide lower costs for all patients.
- Bob's Discount Furniture IPO Flat: Bob's Discount Furniture debuted on the NYSE at $17 per share, valuing the company at $2.22 billion, and while its performance was relatively stable, market enthusiasm for upcoming IPOs remains high.
See More
Stellantis Expects $26 Billion Loss from Overhaul
- Stellantis Stock Plunge: Stellantis shares fell over 25% after the automaker announced it expects a $26 billion loss from a business overhaul, marking a tough start to 2026 with shares down more than 12% year-to-date.
- Amazon Earnings Miss: Amazon's stock dropped over 8% despite beating fourth-quarter revenue expectations, as earnings per share fell short, raising investor concerns about its $200 billion capital expenditure plan, which is set to double by the end of 2027.
- Launch of TrumpRx Platform: Former President Trump officially launched the long-anticipated TrumpRx platform aimed at lowering prescription drug prices in the U.S., though experts doubt its effectiveness in addressing broader affordability issues since it does not directly sell drugs.
- Bob's Discount Furniture IPO Performance: Bob's Discount Furniture debuted on the New York Stock Exchange at $17 per share, valuing the company at $2.22 billion, while other retailers like Peloton and Estée Lauder faced significant stock declines, highlighting market volatility.
See More
