Hagerty Leads the Pack as Top Insurance Broker Year-to-Date
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Dec 23 2025
0mins
Should l Buy HGTY?
Source: SeekingAlpha
Financial Sector Performance: The S&P 500 financials sector has risen about 14% year to date in 2025, ranking as the fourth-best performing sector in the index.
Top Performing Insurance Stocks: Hagerty leads the insurance broker stocks with a YTD performance of +40.52% and a Strong Buy rating, while the Baldwin Insurance Group has the lowest performance at -38.36% with a Strong Sell rating.
Sub-sector Rankings: Other notable insurance stocks include Willis Towers Watson with a +6.12% gain and Aon plc at -1.03%, with several companies showing negative YTD performance.
Market Insights: The article also mentions financial ETFs and highlights that Nasdaq is the best performing financial exchange stock YTD, with Robinhood being the top performing brokerage stock.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy HGTY?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on HGTY
Wall Street analysts forecast HGTY stock price to rise over the next 12 months. According to Wall Street analysts, the average 1-year price target for HGTY is 13.50 USD with a low forecast of 11.00 USD and a high forecast of 15.00 USD. However, analyst price targets are subjective and often lag stock prices, so investors should focus on the objective reasons behind analyst rating changes, which better reflect the company's fundamentals.
4 Analyst Rating
1 Buy
3 Hold
0 Sell
Hold
Current: 12.630
Low
11.00
Averages
13.50
High
15.00
Current: 12.630
Low
11.00
Averages
13.50
High
15.00
About HGTY
Hagerty, Inc. is an automotive enthusiast brand. The Company is a provider of specialty vehicle insurance, expert car valuation data and insights, live and digital car auction services, immersive events and automotive entertainment custom made for the Americans who self-describe as car enthusiasts. Through its insurance business, the Company acts as a Managing General Agent (MGA) by underwriting, selling, and servicing collector car and enthusiast vehicle insurance policies. In addition, the Company offers Hagerty Drivers Club (HDC) memberships, which are primarily bundled with its insurance policies and give subscribers access to an array of products and services, including emergency roadside assistance, Hagerty Drivers Club Magazine, automotive enthusiast events, its proprietary vehicle valuation tool, and special vehicle-related discounts. It provides insurance for approximately 2.6 million collector cars and enthusiast vehicles.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
Broad Arrow Auctions Sets New Records in Global Icons Series
- Record Auction Total: Broad Arrow Auctions' Global Icons online auction series achieved over €18.3 million in total sales, with 90% of lots sold, reflecting strong demand from global collectors for classic cars and memorabilia, thereby solidifying its leadership position in the collector car auction market.
- Michael Schumacher's Race Car Auction: The 1992 Benetton B192-05 sold for €5.082 million, becoming the star of the auction, and its first-ever public sale attracted immense interest from collectors worldwide, highlighting its significant place in racing history.
- Ferrari Sets Auction Record: The 2003 Ferrari 360 Challenge Stradale fetched €561,000, setting a European auction record for the model, demonstrating the ongoing vibrancy of the high-end car market and the strong demand for rare models.
- Diverse Auction Appeal: The auction featured classic models such as the 1955 Lancia Aurelia B24 S Spider and the 1971 Lamborghini Miura P400 S, the latter selling for €1.716 million, further proving the sustained interest and investment value of classic cars in the collector market.
See More
Hagerty Executive Sells 50,000 Shares in Open Market Transaction
- Transaction Overview: Kenneth Ahn, President of Hagerty Marketplace, executed an indirect sale of 50,000 Class A Common Stock shares on January 26, 2026, for approximately $620,500, indicating executive liquidity management within the company.
- Ownership Change Analysis: Post-transaction, Ahn retains 113,593 direct shares while eliminating all indirect equity exposure, effectively managing his risk profile and maintaining direct investment in Hagerty.
- Financial Performance Highlights: Hagerty reported a record net income of $20.85 million in Q3 of fiscal year 2025, marking a 327% year-over-year increase, showcasing its robust performance in the specialty insurance market.
- Market Outlook: Hagerty's stock surged approximately 38% in 2025, and with strong financials and a profitable subscriber base, the company presents an attractive investment opportunity for those seeking exposure to the auto insurance sector.
See More
Kenneth Ahn Sells Shares of Hagerty Marketplace
- Transaction Overview: Kenneth Ahn indirectly sold 50,000 shares of Hagerty, Inc. through Quadrifoglio Holdings LLC for a total transaction value of $620,500 at a price of $12.41 per share, reflecting confidence in the market.
- Holding Proportion Analysis: This transaction represented 100% of Ahn's indirect holdings and 30.56% of his total position, indicating his significant stake and expectations for the company's future market performance.
- Financial Performance Highlights: Hagerty reported a record net income of $20.85 in Q3 of fiscal year 2025, marking the highest quarterly earnings since going public, with an impressive year-over-year increase of approximately 327%, showcasing strong financial health.
- Market Outlook: Hagerty's stock price surged approximately 38% in 2025, and with its unique insurance offerings and profitable subscriber base, the company presents substantial investment potential in the auto insurance market.
See More
1938 Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B Wins Best of the Best Award 2025
- Award Recognition: The 1938 Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B won the Best of Show at The Amelia Concours and was named the Best of the Best Award 2025, highlighting its exceptional status in the global automotive community.
- Historical Significance: Ordered by famed Italian racer Giuseppe Farina in 1938, this vehicle is believed to be one of the prototypes for the 1938 Mille Miglia, representing the pinnacle of automotive engineering of its time.
- Design and Craftsmanship: The Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B exemplifies a moment when performance, design, and craftsmanship aligned perfectly, resonating with car enthusiasts even today and underscoring its significance in automotive history.
- Upcoming Events: The Amelia Concours will take place from March 5-8, 2026, featuring various activities including the Concours d'Elegance and auctions, attracting numerous automotive enthusiasts.
See More
1938 Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B Wins Best of the Best 2025
- Best in Show Award: The 1938 Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B won the Best of Show at The Amelia Concours d'Elegance, showcasing its exceptional design and craftsmanship, thereby reinforcing the brand's position in the classic car market.
- Market Impact: The award not only enhances the vehicle's market value but also attracts more collectors and enthusiasts, potentially driving up future auction prices and increasing brand influence.
- Heritage Recognition: As a classic car manufacturer, Alfa Romeo's recognition of its historically significant model underscores its importance in automotive history, inspiring a new generation of designers and engineers.
- Event Prestige Boost: This accolade elevates The Amelia Concours d'Elegance's international reputation, attracting more high-end automotive brands to participate, further promoting the dissemination and development of classic car culture.
See More
Broad Arrow Auctions to Showcase €8.5M Race Car at Paris Preview Events
- Auction Preview Events: Broad Arrow Auctions will host a preview at Roland-Garros Stadium in Paris, showcasing several collector cars including the Benetton B192 raced by Michael Schumacher to his first victory, valued at over €8.5 million, which is expected to attract global collectors and enhance brand visibility.
- Global Auction Series: This event is part of Broad Arrow's Global Icons Online Auction series, featuring classic cars from multiple countries, further solidifying its leadership position in the global collector car auction market and likely drawing more high-end clients.
- Historical Treasures Display: The exhibition will also feature the limited edition 1913 Type 18 Bugatti 'Black Bess', one of the fastest street-legal cars of its time, highlighting Broad Arrow's commitment to automotive history while appealing to collectors interested in classic vehicles.
- Diverse Auction Offerings: Broad Arrow will showcase various classic models, including the 1971 Lamborghini Miura P400 S and the 1990 Ferrari F40, which are expected to attract a wide buyer demographic, further driving growth in its auction business.
See More
Broad Arrow Auctions Sets New Records in Global Icons Series
- Record Auction Total: Broad Arrow Auctions' Global Icons online auction series achieved over €18.3 million in total sales, with 90% of lots sold, reflecting strong demand from global collectors for classic cars and memorabilia, thereby solidifying its leadership position in the collector car auction market.
- Michael Schumacher's Race Car Auction: The 1992 Benetton B192-05 sold for €5.082 million, becoming the star of the auction, and its first-ever public sale attracted immense interest from collectors worldwide, highlighting its significant place in racing history.
- Ferrari Sets Auction Record: The 2003 Ferrari 360 Challenge Stradale fetched €561,000, setting a European auction record for the model, demonstrating the ongoing vibrancy of the high-end car market and the strong demand for rare models.
- Diverse Auction Appeal: The auction featured classic models such as the 1955 Lancia Aurelia B24 S Spider and the 1971 Lamborghini Miura P400 S, the latter selling for €1.716 million, further proving the sustained interest and investment value of classic cars in the collector market.
See More
Hagerty Executive Sells 50,000 Shares in Open Market Transaction
- Transaction Overview: Kenneth Ahn, President of Hagerty Marketplace, executed an indirect sale of 50,000 Class A Common Stock shares on January 26, 2026, for approximately $620,500, indicating executive liquidity management within the company.
- Ownership Change Analysis: Post-transaction, Ahn retains 113,593 direct shares while eliminating all indirect equity exposure, effectively managing his risk profile and maintaining direct investment in Hagerty.
- Financial Performance Highlights: Hagerty reported a record net income of $20.85 million in Q3 of fiscal year 2025, marking a 327% year-over-year increase, showcasing its robust performance in the specialty insurance market.
- Market Outlook: Hagerty's stock surged approximately 38% in 2025, and with strong financials and a profitable subscriber base, the company presents an attractive investment opportunity for those seeking exposure to the auto insurance sector.
See More
Kenneth Ahn Sells Shares of Hagerty Marketplace
- Transaction Overview: Kenneth Ahn indirectly sold 50,000 shares of Hagerty, Inc. through Quadrifoglio Holdings LLC for a total transaction value of $620,500 at a price of $12.41 per share, reflecting confidence in the market.
- Holding Proportion Analysis: This transaction represented 100% of Ahn's indirect holdings and 30.56% of his total position, indicating his significant stake and expectations for the company's future market performance.
- Financial Performance Highlights: Hagerty reported a record net income of $20.85 in Q3 of fiscal year 2025, marking the highest quarterly earnings since going public, with an impressive year-over-year increase of approximately 327%, showcasing strong financial health.
- Market Outlook: Hagerty's stock price surged approximately 38% in 2025, and with its unique insurance offerings and profitable subscriber base, the company presents substantial investment potential in the auto insurance market.
See More
1938 Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B Wins Best of the Best Award 2025
- Award Recognition: The 1938 Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B won the Best of Show at The Amelia Concours and was named the Best of the Best Award 2025, highlighting its exceptional status in the global automotive community.
- Historical Significance: Ordered by famed Italian racer Giuseppe Farina in 1938, this vehicle is believed to be one of the prototypes for the 1938 Mille Miglia, representing the pinnacle of automotive engineering of its time.
- Design and Craftsmanship: The Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B exemplifies a moment when performance, design, and craftsmanship aligned perfectly, resonating with car enthusiasts even today and underscoring its significance in automotive history.
- Upcoming Events: The Amelia Concours will take place from March 5-8, 2026, featuring various activities including the Concours d'Elegance and auctions, attracting numerous automotive enthusiasts.
See More
1938 Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B Wins Best of the Best 2025
- Best in Show Award: The 1938 Alfa Romeo 8C 2900B won the Best of Show at The Amelia Concours d'Elegance, showcasing its exceptional design and craftsmanship, thereby reinforcing the brand's position in the classic car market.
- Market Impact: The award not only enhances the vehicle's market value but also attracts more collectors and enthusiasts, potentially driving up future auction prices and increasing brand influence.
- Heritage Recognition: As a classic car manufacturer, Alfa Romeo's recognition of its historically significant model underscores its importance in automotive history, inspiring a new generation of designers and engineers.
- Event Prestige Boost: This accolade elevates The Amelia Concours d'Elegance's international reputation, attracting more high-end automotive brands to participate, further promoting the dissemination and development of classic car culture.
See More
Broad Arrow Auctions to Showcase €8.5M Race Car at Paris Preview Events
- Auction Preview Events: Broad Arrow Auctions will host a preview at Roland-Garros Stadium in Paris, showcasing several collector cars including the Benetton B192 raced by Michael Schumacher to his first victory, valued at over €8.5 million, which is expected to attract global collectors and enhance brand visibility.
- Global Auction Series: This event is part of Broad Arrow's Global Icons Online Auction series, featuring classic cars from multiple countries, further solidifying its leadership position in the global collector car auction market and likely drawing more high-end clients.
- Historical Treasures Display: The exhibition will also feature the limited edition 1913 Type 18 Bugatti 'Black Bess', one of the fastest street-legal cars of its time, highlighting Broad Arrow's commitment to automotive history while appealing to collectors interested in classic vehicles.
- Diverse Auction Offerings: Broad Arrow will showcase various classic models, including the 1971 Lamborghini Miura P400 S and the 1990 Ferrari F40, which are expected to attract a wide buyer demographic, further driving growth in its auction business.
See More
