Jim Cramer Favors Agnico over Perpetua Resources
Written by Emily J. Thompson, Senior Investment Analyst
Updated: Dec 19 2025
0mins
Should l Buy PPTA?
Source: Yahoo Finance
Cramer's Commentary: Jim Cramer discussed Perpetua Resources Corp. (PPTA) during a lightning round, suggesting investors consider Agnico instead, despite acknowledging PPTA as a "hot stock."
Company Overview: Perpetua Resources is a mining company focused on gold, silver, and antimony, recently partnering with Idaho National Laboratory to develop a pilot processing plant for defense minerals.
National Security Commitment: The partnership aims to enhance U.S. mineral independence and job creation, with the pilot plant set to produce military-grade antimony trisulfide for defense applications.
Investment Perspective: While PPTA shows potential, the article suggests that certain AI stocks may offer better investment opportunities with higher upside and lower risk.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Stop guessing "Should I Buy PPTA?" and start using high-conviction signals backed by rigorous historical data.
Sign up today to access powerful investing tools and make smarter, data-driven decisions.
Analyst Views on PPTA
Wall Street analysts forecast PPTA stock price to rise
5 Analyst Rating
5 Buy
0 Hold
0 Sell
Strong Buy
Current: 27.570
Low
30.00
Averages
32.72
High
40.00
Current: 27.570
Low
30.00
Averages
32.72
High
40.00
About PPTA
Perpetua Resources Corp. is a development-stage company. The Company operates through mineral exploration in the United States segment. It is primarily engaged in acquiring mining properties with the intention of exploring, evaluating, and placing them into production. The Company’s principal business is the exploration and subject to receipt of required permitting, redevelopment, restoration and operation of the Stibnite Gold Project in Idaho, the United States. Its Stibnite Gold Project is located in central Idaho, the United States, which lies over 100 miles northeast of Boise, Idaho, over 38 miles east of McCall, Idaho, and approximately 10 miles east of Yellow Pine, Idaho. Its mineral Stibnite Gold Project contains gold, silver, and antimony mineral deposits. It focuses to explore, evaluate, and potentially redevelop three of the deposits known as the Hangar Flats Deposit, West End Deposit and Yellow Pine Deposit.
About the author
Emily J. Thompson
Emily J. Thompson, a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) with 12 years in investment research, graduated with honors from the Wharton School. Specializing in industrial and technology stocks, she provides in-depth analysis for Intellectia’s earnings and market brief reports.
NevGold Corp Reports Positive Drill Results at Limousine Butte Project
- Mineralization Expansion: NevGold Corp has reported significant gold-antimony mineralization at its Limousine Butte Project in Nevada, with LB25-019 hole showing 12.42 g/t AuEq, indicating an expanding mineralization footprint that could enhance future Mineral Resource Estimates.
- Drilling Results: The ongoing 2025-2026 drilling program has completed 30 holes, all of which intercepted significant gold-antimony mineralization, particularly LB25-013 which showed 1.37 g/t AuEq over 21.4 meters, highlighting the project's substantial mineralization potential.
- Strategic Importance: Antimony is classified as a critical mineral by the U.S., and the high-grade antimony mineralization at the Limousine Butte project not only addresses domestic demand but may also play a crucial role in future production amid global supply constraints.
- Project Development Plans: NevGold plans to advance the Limousine Butte project in 2025-2026, including metallurgical testing and Mineral Resource Estimates, aiming for near-term production and cash flow generation.
See More
China's Export Restrictions Reshape Global Mining Landscape
- Strategic Shift: China's export restrictions on silver, tungsten, and antimony signal a major strategic shift in global procurement, prompting the U.S. government to mobilize over $30 billion to secure critical mineral supply chains, thereby elevating defense priorities significantly.
- Resource Development Plan: RUA GOLD Inc. has initiated an aggressive development plan with four drill rigs at the Reefton Goldfield in New Zealand, planning to submit a fast-track referral application in Q1 2026, which, if approved, would enter the fastest six-month permitting window globally, significantly accelerating project timelines.
- High-Grade Discovery: Drilling at the Auld Creek target revealed a significant intersection of 3.0 meters at 21.27 g/t AuEq, extending the deposit strike length to 870 meters, indicating substantial mineral potential in the area that could attract further investment.
- M&A Trends: The 2026 mining M&A landscape focuses on consolidation and supply chain security, with Eldorado Gold's merger with Foran Mining expected to generate approximately $2.1 billion in EBITDA annually, further solidifying its leadership position in the gold-copper sector.
See More
Analysis of Perpetua Resources Corp Options Trading
- Options Selling Risks: Selling puts does not provide investors with the same upside potential as owning shares, as the put seller only acquires shares if the contract is exercised, and unless Perpetua Resources Corp's shares decline by 25.8%, the only benefit is a 16.3% annualized return from the premium.
- Strike Price Analysis: At the $20 strike price, the put seller only profits if exercising the option yields a better outcome than selling at the market price, necessitating careful market evaluation to avoid losses.
- Volatility Consideration: With a trailing twelve-month volatility of 84% for Perpetua Resources Corp, this metric, combined with fundamental analysis, aids investors in assessing whether selling the January 2027 put at the $20 strike is a worthwhile risk.
- Yield Assessment: The only profit from selling puts comes from the collected premium, and if the stock price does not meet the exercise conditions, investors must weigh the risks against the potential 16.3% annualized return.
See More
Pentagon Invests $4.5 Billion in Critical Minerals
- Surge in Government Investment: The Pentagon's $4.5 billion investment in critical minerals during the last months of 2025 is expected to lead to record levels of government support for strategic mineral projects in 2026, enhancing competitiveness for companies in defense and technology sectors.
- Mineral Discovery: GoldHaven Resources has confirmed a mineral system across 36,973 hectares at its Magno Project in British Columbia, showcasing potential for copper, gold, silver, lead, zinc, and tungsten, which could significantly enhance the company's resource development opportunities.
- High-Grade Mineralization Validation: Surface sampling at the Magno Zone revealed copper values up to 6,660 ppm, indicating the presence of high-grade copper mineralization within the rocks, further supporting the project's economic viability and future drilling plans.
- Multiple Projects Advancing: GoldHaven has completed diamond drilling at its Copeçal Gold Project in Brazil and confirmed high-grade copper at Three Guardsmen, now controlling 133,186 hectares across mining jurisdictions, demonstrating strong momentum in advancing multiple mining projects simultaneously.
See More
Perpetua Resources (PPTA) Stock Surpasses Analyst Target Price at $34.86
- Price Breakthrough: Perpetua Resources Corp (PPTA) shares recently traded at $34.86, surpassing the average analyst 12-month target price of $33.58, indicating optimistic market sentiment regarding the company's prospects.
- Analyst Reactions: As the stock exceeds the target price, analysts may either downgrade their valuations or raise their target prices, reflecting differing views on the company's improving fundamentals, which could influence investor decisions.
- Target Price Distribution: Among analysts covered by Zacks, target prices range from $30.00 to $40.00, with a standard deviation of $3.835, illustrating varying expectations for PPTA's future performance in the market.
- Investor Signal: The rise in PPTA's stock price provides investors with a strong signal to reassess the company, prompting them to consider whether the current valuation is justified or if it might be time to take profits.
See More
NevGold Corp. Reports High-Grade Gold-Antimony Discovery at Limousine Butte Project
- High-Grade Discovery: NevGold has reported a significant high-grade gold-antimony discovery at its Limousine Butte Project in Nevada, with assays showing up to 23.01 g/t AuEq and 5.89% Sb, which is expected to enhance the project's mineral resource potential and drive future resource estimates.
- Expansion Drilling Results: The company's drilling at Resurrection Ridge has revealed a new oxide gold discovery 150 meters east of previous drilling, with assays indicating 1.03 g/t AuEq, further validating NevGold's geological model and likely attracting increased investment and interest.
- Ongoing Drilling Plans: NevGold plans to continue follow-up drilling in 2026 to expand the identified mineralization, having completed 30 drill holes to date, which demonstrates the area's mineralization potential and may lay the groundwork for future production.
- Strategic Importance: Antimony is classified as a critical mineral by the U.S., and NevGold's discovery not only strengthens its position in the domestic antimony supply chain but also holds significant implications for national security and the economy, especially amid global supply constraints.
See More
NevGold Corp Reports Positive Drill Results at Limousine Butte Project
- Mineralization Expansion: NevGold Corp has reported significant gold-antimony mineralization at its Limousine Butte Project in Nevada, with LB25-019 hole showing 12.42 g/t AuEq, indicating an expanding mineralization footprint that could enhance future Mineral Resource Estimates.
- Drilling Results: The ongoing 2025-2026 drilling program has completed 30 holes, all of which intercepted significant gold-antimony mineralization, particularly LB25-013 which showed 1.37 g/t AuEq over 21.4 meters, highlighting the project's substantial mineralization potential.
- Strategic Importance: Antimony is classified as a critical mineral by the U.S., and the high-grade antimony mineralization at the Limousine Butte project not only addresses domestic demand but may also play a crucial role in future production amid global supply constraints.
- Project Development Plans: NevGold plans to advance the Limousine Butte project in 2025-2026, including metallurgical testing and Mineral Resource Estimates, aiming for near-term production and cash flow generation.
See More
China's Export Restrictions Reshape Global Mining Landscape
- Strategic Shift: China's export restrictions on silver, tungsten, and antimony signal a major strategic shift in global procurement, prompting the U.S. government to mobilize over $30 billion to secure critical mineral supply chains, thereby elevating defense priorities significantly.
- Resource Development Plan: RUA GOLD Inc. has initiated an aggressive development plan with four drill rigs at the Reefton Goldfield in New Zealand, planning to submit a fast-track referral application in Q1 2026, which, if approved, would enter the fastest six-month permitting window globally, significantly accelerating project timelines.
- High-Grade Discovery: Drilling at the Auld Creek target revealed a significant intersection of 3.0 meters at 21.27 g/t AuEq, extending the deposit strike length to 870 meters, indicating substantial mineral potential in the area that could attract further investment.
- M&A Trends: The 2026 mining M&A landscape focuses on consolidation and supply chain security, with Eldorado Gold's merger with Foran Mining expected to generate approximately $2.1 billion in EBITDA annually, further solidifying its leadership position in the gold-copper sector.
See More
Analysis of Perpetua Resources Corp Options Trading
- Options Selling Risks: Selling puts does not provide investors with the same upside potential as owning shares, as the put seller only acquires shares if the contract is exercised, and unless Perpetua Resources Corp's shares decline by 25.8%, the only benefit is a 16.3% annualized return from the premium.
- Strike Price Analysis: At the $20 strike price, the put seller only profits if exercising the option yields a better outcome than selling at the market price, necessitating careful market evaluation to avoid losses.
- Volatility Consideration: With a trailing twelve-month volatility of 84% for Perpetua Resources Corp, this metric, combined with fundamental analysis, aids investors in assessing whether selling the January 2027 put at the $20 strike is a worthwhile risk.
- Yield Assessment: The only profit from selling puts comes from the collected premium, and if the stock price does not meet the exercise conditions, investors must weigh the risks against the potential 16.3% annualized return.
See More
Pentagon Invests $4.5 Billion in Critical Minerals
- Surge in Government Investment: The Pentagon's $4.5 billion investment in critical minerals during the last months of 2025 is expected to lead to record levels of government support for strategic mineral projects in 2026, enhancing competitiveness for companies in defense and technology sectors.
- Mineral Discovery: GoldHaven Resources has confirmed a mineral system across 36,973 hectares at its Magno Project in British Columbia, showcasing potential for copper, gold, silver, lead, zinc, and tungsten, which could significantly enhance the company's resource development opportunities.
- High-Grade Mineralization Validation: Surface sampling at the Magno Zone revealed copper values up to 6,660 ppm, indicating the presence of high-grade copper mineralization within the rocks, further supporting the project's economic viability and future drilling plans.
- Multiple Projects Advancing: GoldHaven has completed diamond drilling at its Copeçal Gold Project in Brazil and confirmed high-grade copper at Three Guardsmen, now controlling 133,186 hectares across mining jurisdictions, demonstrating strong momentum in advancing multiple mining projects simultaneously.
See More
Perpetua Resources (PPTA) Stock Surpasses Analyst Target Price at $34.86
- Price Breakthrough: Perpetua Resources Corp (PPTA) shares recently traded at $34.86, surpassing the average analyst 12-month target price of $33.58, indicating optimistic market sentiment regarding the company's prospects.
- Analyst Reactions: As the stock exceeds the target price, analysts may either downgrade their valuations or raise their target prices, reflecting differing views on the company's improving fundamentals, which could influence investor decisions.
- Target Price Distribution: Among analysts covered by Zacks, target prices range from $30.00 to $40.00, with a standard deviation of $3.835, illustrating varying expectations for PPTA's future performance in the market.
- Investor Signal: The rise in PPTA's stock price provides investors with a strong signal to reassess the company, prompting them to consider whether the current valuation is justified or if it might be time to take profits.
See More
NevGold Corp. Reports High-Grade Gold-Antimony Discovery at Limousine Butte Project
- High-Grade Discovery: NevGold has reported a significant high-grade gold-antimony discovery at its Limousine Butte Project in Nevada, with assays showing up to 23.01 g/t AuEq and 5.89% Sb, which is expected to enhance the project's mineral resource potential and drive future resource estimates.
- Expansion Drilling Results: The company's drilling at Resurrection Ridge has revealed a new oxide gold discovery 150 meters east of previous drilling, with assays indicating 1.03 g/t AuEq, further validating NevGold's geological model and likely attracting increased investment and interest.
- Ongoing Drilling Plans: NevGold plans to continue follow-up drilling in 2026 to expand the identified mineralization, having completed 30 drill holes to date, which demonstrates the area's mineralization potential and may lay the groundwork for future production.
- Strategic Importance: Antimony is classified as a critical mineral by the U.S., and NevGold's discovery not only strengthens its position in the domestic antimony supply chain but also holds significant implications for national security and the economy, especially amid global supply constraints.
See More
