CarMax Faces Growing Credit Concerns: November Data Reveals Weak Trends and Increasing Defaults
CarMax's November Trends: CarMax's CAF securitization data indicates soft trends in November, with a sequential increase in delinquency rates, consistent with historical averages, as noted by analyst Scott Devitt.
Analyst Rating: Scott Devitt maintains a Neutral rating for CarMax with a price target of $40, suggesting that delinquencies may continue to rise until the tax refund period.
Investor Concerns: There are growing concerns among investors regarding CarMax's credit exposure and management's ability to maintain market leadership.
Stock Performance: CarMax shares saw a slight increase of 0.87%, trading at $40.98, with potential investment exposure available through various ETFs.
Trade with 70% Backtested Accuracy
Analyst Views on XRT
About the author

Consumer Discretionary Performance: Consumer discretionary stocks have seen minimal growth, with only a 2% increase over the past year as indicated by the Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF.
Comparison with Other S&P Sectors: Among the 11 major S&P sectors, consumer discretionary stocks performed poorly, with only financials showing worse performance, remaining unchanged over the same period.
S&P 500 Growth: In contrast, the S&P 500 has experienced a more robust gain of 12% over the past year, highlighting the underperformance of consumer discretionary and financial sectors.
Market Trends: The overall market trends suggest a challenging environment for consumer discretionary stocks, reflecting broader economic conditions affecting consumer spending.
Market Performance: The bull run in the market continued, with both the S&P 500 and the Dow Jones Industrial Average reaching record highs.
Investor Sentiment: The ongoing upward trend indicates strong investor confidence and optimism in the market's future performance.
- Shift in Consumer Spending: People are expected to move their spending habits from services and experiences to physical goods.
- Focus on Physical Goods: There will be an increased emphasis on purchasing items such as houses and furniture.
Costco's Performance in 2025: Costco Wholesale faced challenges in 2025, impacting its overall performance.
Potential for Recovery: The company has the potential to rebound in the current year with the right catalysts.
Investor Sentiment: Despite recent difficulties, Costco remains a favorite among Wall Street investors.
Need for Catalysts: To regain momentum, Costco requires specific triggers to jumpstart its growth.
- Costco's Performance in 2025: Costco Wholesale faced challenges in 2025, impacting its overall performance.
- Potential for Recovery: The company has the potential to rebound in the current year with the right catalysts.
- Investor Sentiment: Despite difficulties, Costco remains a favorite among Wall Street investors.
- Need for Catalysts: To regain momentum, Costco requires specific triggers to jumpstart its growth.

Holiday Spending Increase: Consumers spent 3.9% more this holiday season compared to last year, driven by the convenience of online shopping, according to Mastercard's SpendingPulse retail sales study.
Online vs. In-Store Sales: Online sales rose by 7.4%, while in-store shopping saw a modest increase of 2.9%. The gap narrowed for clothing sales, with online apparel up 8.5% and in-store up 7.0%.
Dining Out Expenditure: Spending on dining out increased by 5.2% during the holiday shopping period, reflecting consumer confidence and flexibility in their spending habits.
Record Holiday Spending Forecast: The National Retail Federation forecasts U.S. consumers will spend a record $1 trillion during the holidays, translating to approximately $890 per person on gifts, food, and decorations.









